How to Write Evaluation in A-Level Economics: A Guide for H1 and H2 Students
JC Economics Education Centre
“The policy’s effectiveness depends on price elasticity of demand.” This is a common sentence in A-Level Economics answers. It identifies a relevant condition, but the reader still needs to know what makes demand more or less price responsive in this market and how that affects the policy’s success.
A strong evaluation answers three questions. What is the policy trying to achieve? What condition could change the result? What judgement follows in this case?
What is the difference between analysis and evaluation in Economics?
Analysis explains how an outcome occurs. Evaluation judges how significant or likely that outcome is in the circumstances.
For example, analysis can explain how a subsidy lowers the price of a service and increases its use. Evaluation can then ask whether the subsidy reaches people who would otherwise go without the service, how much extra use it generates, and whether that is enough to achieve the policy objective.
Worked example: Will a subsidy increase flu vaccination among older adults?
Practice question
Assess whether subsidising influenza vaccination is likely to increase vaccination among older adults.
1. Explain how the subsidy works
A subsidy can lower the price older adults pay for a flu vaccination. Those who previously considered vaccination too expensive may now be willing and able to get it, increasing the quantity demanded. Higher vaccination uptake can also benefit others by reducing transmission risk.
2. Identify what could limit the effect
Suppose the case study says some older adults skip vaccination because they find it difficult to travel to a clinic. A lower price addresses the financial barrier, while the time and effort needed to reach the clinic remain. Uptake may therefore rise only modestly among the people facing the greatest access difficulties.
That gives the answer a basis for comparing policies. If affordability is the main barrier, a subsidy can directly address it. If travel is the main barrier, vaccination sessions at accessible community locations may have a larger effect on uptake.
3. Write a judgement that follows from the evidence
The subsidy is likely to increase vaccination among older adults who can reach a clinic and are discouraged mainly by cost. Its effect will be smaller where travel is the main barrier. If the evidence shows that many unvaccinated older adults have difficulty reaching a clinic, bringing vaccination closer to them is likely to do more to raise uptake in that group.
The judgement identifies the group most likely to benefit, the condition that limits the policy, and the evidence that would support a different approach.
How should evaluation differ in H1 case studies and H2 essays?
| Question type | How to develop your evaluation |
|---|---|
| H1 or H2 case study | Use a specific detail from the extract to explain why an effect may be stronger or weaker in the situation given. |
| H2 essay | When the question calls for comparison, judge the policies against the same objective. Explain which is likely to work better under the conditions you have identified. |
For case study practice, see the [H1 Economics case study guide](/h1-economics-tuition-singapore-case-study-guide/). For essay practice, see the [H2 Economics essay guide](/h2-economics-tuition-singapore-essay-guide/).
How can students practise evaluation before the exam?
Pick a paragraph where your teacher wrote “evaluation is too general.” Underline the condition you named and add a sentence explaining how it changes the outcome. Then read your conclusion alongside the question. If the question asks about vaccination uptake, your final judgement should explain how far uptake is likely to rise and which group is most affected.
A-Level Economics tuition with Dr Anthony Fok
Dr Anthony Fok teaches JC1 and JC2 H1 and H2 Economics at JC Economics Education Centre. Students practise using evidence, developing economic arguments and writing judgements that answer the question. Weekly group classes are held in Bishan, Bukit Timah and Tampines.
View the 2027 JC Economics tuition schedule · WhatsApp 8251 3684
